Bus Groups Ask FMCSA to Preempt NYC Idling Law
The American Bus Association and United Motorcoach Association filed a petition, dated May 27, 2026, asking FMCSA Administrator Derek Barrs to find New York City's engine-idling rules preempted under 49 U.S.C. 31141. The document was posted November 17, 2026, in new docket FMCSA-2026-4159.
The groups argue NYC Admin Code 24-163 — a 3-minute idling limit, a ban on any idling at bus terminal points above 40°F, and a 1-minute limit near schools and parks — conflicts with FMCSA's pre-trip inspection rule (49 CFR 396.13) and the reasonable passenger-cabin temperature rule (49 CFR 374.313(a)). They say the rules have no safety benefit, are incompatible with federal regulations, and burden interstate commerce because city-owned and transit buses are effectively exempt from penalties.
The petition cites member Academy Express, which it says received 200 citations in one day totaling $120,000 in fines, and a city 'bounty hunter' complaint program that drew 124,000 citizen complaints in 2024. It also details a disputed DEP variance Academy rejected in March 2026 that tied idling relief to mandatory EV and auxiliary-power-unit purchases.
The petition asks FMCSA to preempt the law for private buses carrying 15 or more passengers.
What's next
- FMCSA has not set a comment period or ruling date in the posted material.
- Watch docket FMCSA-2026-4159 for FMCSA's response or a notice seeking public comment.
All sources

