Arizona Court Splits on Broker Negligence, Contract Claims
Judge Diane Humetewa ruled on a motion to amend in a cargo-theft suit by shipper Dyson Incorporated against Integrity Logistics. Dyson sued under the Carmack Amendment after 1,440 hair dryers valued at $466,315.20 were stolen while in Integrity's custody. Integrity answered that it acted only as a broker, not a carrier, and so cannot be liable under Carmack.
Dyson sought to add alternative claims for negligence, gross negligence, negligent hiring and breach of contract in case Integrity's broker defense succeeds. The court granted leave on breach of contract, finding it enforces privately agreed delivery obligations and is not preempted by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA).
The court denied leave on the negligence and negligent-hiring claims, holding they are preempted. Citing a California district court decision, the order said theft-based negligent-hiring claims against brokers fall outside the FAAAA's safety exception, which only shields claims tied directly to motor vehicle safety.
The case continues on Carmack liability and, now, breach of contract.
What's next
- 2026-11-24: Dyson must file its amended complaint, per the order.
- Integrity Logistics must answer within 14 days of that filing.
- Whether Integrity is a broker or carrier remains undetermined; that finding will decide which claims ultimately apply.
All sources
- Opinion: Dyson Incorporated v. Integrity Logistics Incorporated — Federal court opinion (U.S. District Court District of Arizona), 2026-11-19

