Michigan Court Trims $78M Verdict Against Trucking Firm
The Michigan Court of Appeals ruled on November 20 in a wrongful-death suit against Challenger Motor Freight, Inc. and its driver, Jose Angel Nogueras, over a 2018 crash on I-75 that killed a father and son when Nogueras's tractor-trailer rear-ended their stopped car at over 50 mph. A Wayne County jury had awarded roughly $68 million, which grew to about $78.5 million with interest, including $24 million for the decedents' preimpact fright and shock.
The appeals court said that award can no longer stand. Citing the Michigan Supreme Court's recent decision in Daher v. Prime Healthcare Services, the panel held the wrongful death act only allows the damages categories listed in the statute, and preimpact fright and shock is not one of them. The court vacated that portion of the verdict.
The panel also found the trial court abused its discretion by letting plaintiff substitute an undisclosed expert witness on conscious pain and suffering without giving the defense a chance to depose him. It ordered a new trial on that damages category but affirmed the rest of the judgment, including Challenger's admitted liability.
All sources
- Opinion: Estate of Zachary Attianese v. Jose Angel Nogueras — CourtListener (Michigan Court of Appeals), 2026-11-20

