Sunday, November 22, 2026 Daily BriefMedia WatchFMCSA Newsroom ↗
FreightFiles.com: News, Policy, Courts, Guidance, Rulemaking, Enforcement

Judge Splits J.B. Hunt Broker Liability Ruling in Fatal Crash

So whatBrokers: the no-lease defense beat a vicarious-liability claim, but negligent-selection claims survive on weak carrier vetting. Document your carrier safety reviews now.

The court ruled on J.B. Hunt's motion for summary judgment in a wrongful-death suit over an October 2023 head-on collision on U.S. Route 160 that killed two people and injured three children. Borderlanders Inc., the motor carrier J.B. Hunt tendered the load to, admitted its driver, Shokhijakhon Bekmuradov, caused the crash while passing on a two-lane highway.

Plaintiffs argued J.B. Hunt was vicariously liable as a statutory employer under 49 U.S.C. § 14102 and 49 C.F.R. § 376. The court disagreed, holding those leasing regulations apply only where a qualifying lease exists between carrier and lessee. Because Borderlanders used its own authority, equipment and driver under a broker-carrier agreement, not a lease, the court found no basis for vicarious liability and granted J.B. Hunt summary judgment on that claim.

But the court let the negligent-selection claim proceed. Plaintiffs cited evidence that Borderlanders had 35 crashes in the two years before the accident and monthly FMCSA Safety Assessment alerts for a full year, and that J.B. Hunt never reviewed that history before selecting the carrier. The court said a jury could find J.B. Hunt knew or should have known of the risk.

What's next

  • The negligent-selection claim against J.B. Hunt proceeds toward trial; no trial date is stated in the order.
  • Damages remain undetermined for all parties.

All sources

Related coverage

Judge Splits J.B. Hunt Broker Liability Ruling in Fatal Crash
Illustration generated for FreightFiles.