Court Rejects FMCSR-Based Duty Claim Against FedEx in Death Suit
Chief Judge Timothy L. Brooks granted Federal Express Corporation summary judgment in a wrongful-death suit brought by Advocacy Trust LLC, representative of the estate of Daniel Garcia Jr. Garcia died June 9, 2023, when the 2008 Freightliner MT45 box van he drove overturned on him during a right turn in Benton County, Arkansas. A post-accident inspection flagged brake-system defects.
Garcia worked for Scout Logistics, Inc. (SCL), which owned the van and leased it to FedEx under an Independent Service Provider Agreement. Advocacy Trust argued FedEx owed Garcia a duty of care because 49 C.F.R. § 376.12(c)(1) requires a motor-carrier lessee to assume "complete responsibility" for leased equipment. The court said that regulation alone, incorporated into the lease, did not establish a duty. It noted § 376.12(c)(4) bars using the lease to create an employment relationship, and the ISP Agreement itself assigned maintenance and inspection duties to SCL, not FedEx, which also never owned the truck.
The court also found Advocacy Trust failed to show FedEx's conduct proximately caused the crash. It dismissed the complaint with prejudice, including claims against an unidentified maintenance company never served or named.
What's next
- Watch for whether Advocacy Trust appeals to the Eighth Circuit.
- Carriers should check lease language on maintenance allocation against this ruling's reasoning.
All sources
- Opinion: ADVOCACY TRUST LLC v. FEDERAL EXPRESS CORPORATION — Federal court opinion (U.S. District Court Western District of Arkansas), 2026-11-17

