Sunday, November 22, 2026 Daily BriefMedia WatchFMCSA Newsroom ↗
FreightFiles.com: News, Policy, Courts, Guidance, Rulemaking, Enforcement

Fifth Circuit Upholds Carrier's Jury Win in Broker's Trade-Secret Suit

So whatBrokers & Carriers: the ruling upholds a jury's rejection of a broker's trade secret claims against a carrier; it turns on deferential review standards, not new trade secret law.

Pittsburgh Logistics Systems, a freight broker, sued Glen Rose Transportation Management, a motor carrier, for unjust enrichment and trade secret misappropriation under the Texas Uniform Trade Secrets Act and the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act. A jury in the Western District of Texas (No. 6:20-CV-1173) ruled for Glen Rose. Pittsburgh Logistics appealed both the judgment and the denial of its motion to alter or amend the judgment under Rule 59(e), arguing the trial court wrongly admitted certain testimony and that the verdict lacked evidentiary support.

The Fifth Circuit applied the deferential abuse-of-discretion standard and found Pittsburgh Logistics failed to show it was prejudiced by the testimony at issue, noting the jury was instructed that the broker's customer lists were trade secrets. The court also found no "absolute absence of evidence" supporting the verdict, the standard needed to reverse a Rule 59(e) denial. It affirmed the judgment and the Rule 59(e) ruling.

Glen Rose cross-appealed, arguing the district court erred by not ruling on its pending motion for costs. The panel dismissed the cross-appeal, holding there was no final appealable order because the costs motion remains unresolved below. A footnote and a separate concurrence by Judge Ho address an ex parte meeting between the magistrate judge and a Glen Rose representative who referenced political contacts amid frustration over case delays; the panel found no reversible error since the meeting's contents were later disclosed to both sides.

What's next

  • The district court still must rule on Glen Rose's pending motion for costs.
  • No further appeal was indicated in the opinion as of the filing date.

All sources

Fifth Circuit Issues Opinion in Freight Broker Dispute Case No. 25-50864
Illustration generated for FreightFiles.