States, Injured Drivers Ask PHMSA to Rethink Gasoline Preemption Ruling
New York and 16 other states, the District of Columbia, and Massachusetts and Virginia filed a petition for reconsideration on September 29, 2026, asking PHMSA's Chief Counsel to revisit Preemption Determination No. PD-42(R), according to the filing posted to docket PHMSA-2025-0777. The Locks Law Firm, representing five plaintiffs in pending personal-injury suits, filed a separate petition the same day.
PHMSA's determination, issued September 4, 2026, and published in the Federal Register on September 9 (91 Fed. Reg. 57,439), found the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act and Hazardous Materials Regulations wholly preempt state tort claims over marking, training, loading and hazard classification of gasoline carried by cargo tank motor vehicle. The ruling followed an application from Exxon Mobil Corporation after a New Jersey court denied summary judgment on preemption grounds in Singh v. Exxon Mobil Corp., a case alleging benzene exposure caused blood cancers in tanker drivers and terminal workers.
The states argue PHMSA improperly reviewed a state court's interlocutory order, ignored a savings clause tied to workplace-injury claims, misapplied Supreme Court precedent, and owes no deference to its own preemption conclusions under Loper Bright. The Locks Law Firm raises similar objections and alleges factual errors in the agency's account of the litigation.
What's next
- Comments on the petitions are due to PHMSA's Chief Counsel around October 19, 2026, 20 days after the September 29 mailing.
- No date is set for a final agency ruling on the petitions.
- Watch docket PHMSA-2025-0777 on regulations.gov for additional filings and PHMSA's eventual response.
All sources
Other: Petition for Reconsideration from State of NY et al on PD-42(R) — Regulations.gov (PHMSA), 2026-10-01
Other: Petition for Reconsideration from Locks Law Firm on PD-42(R) — Regulations.gov (PHMSA), 2026-10-01

